Share from 0:00
0:00
/

Hot takes: Three Dons and a nothing burger

Shenzhen made little news, but was revealing for how Trump sees his place in the world

Last week, as Donald Trump prepared to sit down with Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping in Shenzhen, HBO happened to be running a Sopranos marathon. I watched a few episodes. Okay, about a dozen hours. So when Danielle Pletka and I got together for Hot Takes Happy Hour, I couldn’t resist the comparison.

It was a sit-down between the heads of the three families. Different territories, competing interests, plenty of mutual suspicion and everyone insisting on respect. And one guy particularly eager to be photographed with the other bosses.

All three men cast the meeting as historic. Trump called Putin and Xi his friends and praised their personal relationships. On Saturday, he went further, posting a photograph comparing their gathering to the 1945 Yalta Conference, where Franklin Roosevelt, Winston Churchill and Joseph Stalin negotiated the postwar order. Even bigger than Yalta, Trump suggested.

Except Yalta was eight days long and actually produced agreements. Shenzhen was 90 minutes and produced a photo op and a communique so thin it could have been slipped under a hotel door.

The three leaders agreed that nuclear war would be bad, international institutions could use some reform and the world would benefit from more refined petroleum products. There was no breakthrough on Ukraine, no deal on Iran, no nuclear arms-control negotiations and no meaningful resolution of their competing economic interests. For all the talk about making history, they barely managed to make news.

But the meeting revealed something important about how Trump sees the world, and his place in it.

He doesn’t particularly care about sitting around a table with the leaders of Germany, France or Canada, debating the finer points of collective security. He wants to be with the big guys who don’t have to worry about pesky parliaments, independent courts or voters throwing them out of office.

Trump doesn’t just want to negotiate with other leaders. He wants them to understand who’s the boss, though he prefers to call it “respect.” Consider his recent account of negotiations with Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. Trump claimed he told Marcos that the Philippines would buy 100 percent of its energy and agricultural products from the United States. Not 90 percent, or even 95. All of it. Otherwise, they would have “problems.”

Trump arrived in China hoping to demonstrate that he belonged in the world’s most exclusive strongman club. But Xi and Putin have a rather different understanding of the membership rules.

Xi is playing a long game, working with Putin to reshape an international order they believe has favored the United States for too long. Their partnership is rooted in shared strategic interests, not warm feelings. China has helped sustain Russia’s war effort through energy purchases and critical technology, while both leaders see opportunities in weakening American alliances and influence.

Dany and I disagreed about how much the summit rehabilitated Putin. She argued that everyone already knows exactly who he is, and no amount of diplomatic pageantry changes that.

And as she observed, Xi essentially treated Putin like the help. He personally welcomed Trump at the airport with an unusually warm reception. Putin received considerably less affection. At one dinner, Putin found himself seated farther from Xi, beside the Chinese leader’s wife. Fair point.

But Putin still got something he desperately wanted: recognition as an equal of the world’s two largest powers, without making a single concession on Ukraine.

Indeed, while the leaders congratulated themselves on promoting world peace, Russia continued its assault on Ukraine. Within hours of the summit, Russian missiles and drones were again striking Ukrainian infrastructure, triggering emergency power outages.

Here’s where the gangster analogy stops being funny. In the days before Shenzhen, Trump’s envoys, Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff, invited Moscow to discuss a new European security architecture as part of talks to end the war in Ukraine. Putin’s answer was to turn the clock back to 1997, before NATO expanded into Eastern Europe. As I argued last week, Putin didn’t invade Ukraine merely to grab territory. He wants to renegotiate the security order that ended the Cold War, and Washington has handed him an opening.

Dany made a sharp point about a fundamental miscalculation in Trump’s global misadventures: Assuming everyone wants a deal. Some adversaries want victory, and they use negotiations to extract concessions and buy time. Xi and Putin have plenty of time. Trump has just over two years left in office and came out of the midterms weakened. They’re thinking in decades.

Trump was just happy to be invited to the sit-down. Xi and Putin came to collect.

Watch this week’s Hot Takes Happy Hour for our full conversation about the Shenzhen nothingburger, Putin’s ambitions and why Europe still can’t get its act together.

Leave a comment

Share

Three decades covering foreign policy has taught me one thing: the story is almost never as simple as your side wants it to be. That’s why I call balls and strikes without keeping score.

That means you get reporting and analysis that makes partisans on both sides a little uncomfortable. Clear-eyed, fact based, and beholden to no one.

If that’s the kind of coverage you want to read- I hope you will support my work by subscribing or making a contribution

Get more from Elise Labott in the Substack app
Available for iOS and Android

Discussion about this video

User's avatar

Ready for more?